Trace the claim to its evidence

How to Read a Research Paper

Read with a question in mind. Make a first pass for relevance, a second to trace the main claim to evidence, and a deeper pass if you need to rely on the result. Finish with a note that separates what the authors found from what you can reasonably conclude.

By Rain Night Café · 9 November 2026. We make the café linked below. The paper and numbers in the example are fictional.

Use each pass to make one decision

S. Keshav’s original three-pass method moves from a general idea of a paper to its content and then its details. This guide adapts it into a reading note. The sequence is flexible: a theory paper may need a proof check, and a qualitative paper may need close reading of how themes were developed.

  1. Decide whether to keep reading. Read the title, abstract, headings and conclusion. Write the question, context and why it does or does not fit your task.
  2. Find the evidence. Pick one result you might cite. Locate the table, figure or passage, read its caption and check the methods that produced it. Record the units or categories and the comparison.
  3. Test the claim you plan to make. Check who or what was studied, how the comparison was made, and what the authors say they could not establish. Follow a reference if you need a term or method explained.

Worked note: an association is not an intervention

Imagine a paper about a library’s quiet floor. Its fictional Table 2 reports median reported study time of 50 minutes for quiet-floor visitors and 35 minutes for visitors on other floors. The table describes 40 students who chose their own seats. It is a comparison between groups, not a before-and-after measure on the same students.

Too strong: “Moving students to the quiet floor increases study time by 15 minutes.” Better reading note: “In this sample, students who chose the quiet floor reported a median study time 15 minutes higher. Table 2, minutes. The students chose their floor; differences in plans or schedules could affect the comparison.”

Check the denominator, the meaning of the numbers and whether a figure reports uncertainty before drawing a conclusion. If an important detail is missing, leave a question in your note instead of filling it in yourself.

Leave a note someone else could check

When you put that checked finding into your own writing, use our paraphrase comparison to test the wording, meaning and attribution separately. New wording must not turn a narrow finding into a broader claim.

Write five short lines: the research question, the relevant finding, the evidence location, the limitation that changes your interpretation, and what you still need to verify. If a sentence needs a source you have not read, mark it for follow-up. Never cite the fictional example above as evidence.

For several papers, transfer checked notes to a literature review matrix. For a first café block, aim to finish one evidence note rather than an entire paper. Keep papers and private notes in your own tools; the café does not retrieve articles or assess research quality.

Read one result in the free café →Explore Café Pass scenery →

Frequently asked questions

Where should I start when reading a research paper?
Start with your own question, then read the title, abstract, headings and conclusion to decide whether the paper is relevant. Check the methods and results before relying on a claim.
What are the three passes for reading a paper?
Use the first pass to understand the question and relevance, the second to follow the main argument and evidence, and the third to examine assumptions and details when your task requires it.
Can I cite a claim from the abstract alone?
An abstract can help you screen a source. Before relying on a finding, inspect the full results and methods, record where it appears and check which limitations affect your use of it.
Do I need to read every paper three times?
No. Stop after screening if the paper does not answer your question. Go deeper when a result will carry part of your argument, when you are checking quality, or when your assignment requires it.